• About
  • Tai Chi Glossary
  • Tai Chi Guide

Thoughts On Tai Chi

~ My Personal Thoughts About The Art of Tai Chi Chuan as Philosophy and Martial Art

Thoughts On Tai Chi

Monthly Archives: October 2018

Qi on the Inside, Jin on the Outside

30 Tuesday Oct 2018

Posted by David in Basic concepts, General Tai Chi, Personal reflections

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

jin, Qi

In this post, or rather article if you look at the length of it, I will describe the differences and relationships between Qi and Jin, one concept that describes an inner steam and another concept that describes an art specific expression of power. 

In the last post I wrote about the concept of Qi I said that I am not the greatest believer in what this energy can actually do. I don’t really like to speak about qi and I seldom use this term when I teach about Tai Chi. I feel that it’s unnecessary and that it tend to rather complicate things than explain. And still, I tend to write more blog posts about this subject than about anything else. Ironic, isn’t it? For a person who don’t know me very well I must look like one of the greatest promotors of Qi.

But still, even if I don’t like using this word or concept very much, I do accept that it’s a term that is used a whole lot and that it’s necessary to explain things around this concept, about the history and culture so that it can be better comprehended for what it is. One of my Tai Chi teachers, the one that had the most knowledge about Chinese culture and history, he didn’t use this word very much and thought that Qi is a philosophical concept. But this still doesn’t mean that he rejected Qi or even diminished it. I remember one time when a student was showing a qigong posture she was taught from another teacher and spoke about how qi circulated through it. He adjusted her posture slightly and said “now you have qi circulation”.

So even if we should have a bit distance to this concept and try to not over-use it, Qi is certainly still a useful concepts if it’s used right and in the right concept. We use the term Qi in Tai Chi for something we can feel on the inside. When we do certain things right, we can stimulate heat in our bodies, stimulate, keep and circulate, a process that the Chinese used the picture of steam to describe.

An internal process that produces steam

So what we do when we practice Tai Chi is that we follow a certain way to do things practically. We relax our minds by getting rid of our intellectual thought process and making our heart calm and strive for a state of emptiness. We relax our bodies in such a way that the body keeps its own structure erect, we open the joints and keep a relaxed, natural posture. We breath slow and deep and sink the strength down to the feet.

When we do all of this correct we can feel a certain heat. Then when we move, we move with the body as a whole, the movements come rooted from the feet, centered in the Dantian. The limbs move in unison and are directly coordinated from the Dantian and all of the movements follow the breath naturally. We move evenly, carefully, to maintain this heat or steam as we move. When we move, we try to listen to our body’s own wants, how it wants to move, and help it to move rather than forcing the movements.

A common thing people say in the internal martial arts is that “where the Yi go, Qi follows”. If you focus on something, the Qi goes there. But there’s also a saying that you should never focus directly on qi, if you do then it gets stuck. So we should never “think qi” or try to feel the steam. We can not make this feeling stronger by wanting the heat to get stronger. We just need to maintain the basic prerequisites, the conditions that we use to stimulate and keep this heat. The more we practice, the faster we can get into this body-mind state and the better we can feel it.

So the Qi is on the inside, it’s something that happens because we do things right. The problem when we do things more practical, when we practice push hands or even fight, is that we must maintain very much the same conditions as we do when we practice solo exercises and make the Qi flowing. Easier said than done, right? We certainly don’t move slowly when we fight. But we should use a calm, empty mind and be very relaxed. We should sink internally and keep the feeling of being sunk. Maybe we don’t go as deep into ourselves and our meditative state when we try to use Tai Chi for real, but the basic conditions should still be there. We learn these conditions by practicing them to the extreme when we practice solo and controlled push hands exercises. Even if we don’t go as deep and use these conditions in the same extreme manner, we must still maintain them when we do things practically. Only then can our bodies express real Tai Chi Jin.

Use Jin, not Li not Qi

In Tai Chi  people sometimes say “don’t use Li, use Jin”. (Not to be confused with “use Yi instead of Li“) With the word Li we mean the brute, unrefined strength that anyone can use. In the martial arts we want to develop Jin, which is something refined, a skilled use of strength. Every martial art, or at least family of martial arts, have their own refined skills of expressing strength. The practitioners of different arts express strength differently by their own way to use their bodies. The Chinese character jin = 勁 has the part of strength in it, the character for Li =力, but also has the characters for river and work, giving the picture of an underground river, meaning something that flows through something. Or as how Jonathan Bluestein expresses it: “A power that passes through.” How accurate isn’t this about Tai Chi?!

In Tai Chi the term Jin means something Tai Chi specific. Jin is a direct expression of the internal body state. It’s really a power that passes through the body, from the inside to the outside. In Tai Chi, Jin is an external, direct expression of the internal body state. If the internal prerequisites are there, then qi is on the inside and Jin will be expressed on the outside.

Sadly, instead of “use Jin”, many teachers say “don’t use strength, use qi.” This was also something that one of my (least favourite) teachers used to say. But both qi and jin are expressions of the same internal body state (About these basic requisites I also like to use the word “integrity“). My first teacher understood this relationship better from a practical point of view. When he taught two man exercises, as redirecting force methods and applications and similar, he would always nag about the basic state in Tai Chi. He would constantly say things as “don’t tense up”, “relax better”, “sink better”, “sink the breath”, “move from the feet”, etc. But he would never say anything like “use qi.” Instead he would direct you practically to do the internal conditions right, to do things correct in a practical sense. He understood that if you do certain things right, the Jin would automatically be expressed. So expressing Tai Chi Jin is not about what you think or what you believe in, it all still boils down to what you practically do. Even how you think about these matters is only important to the extent that your way of thinking makes you do things correctly.

“Trying to use qi” is not one of these conditions. Let qi stay as the internal expression of the same conditions that make you express jin. Every single time I hear someone in demonstration say things like “now I sink my qi” or “you must sink the qi”, or even something like “I direct my qi into my opponent”, I get annoyed. Why? First, I’ll just point to the fact The Tai Chi classics doesn’t say anything about using qi. The Tai Chi classics doesn’t say “fa qi” or release qi, instead it says “fa jin”,  release jin. In the Tai Chi classics the term Qi is still mentioned. There’s a passage where it says that “the qi sinks”. But this doesn’t say anything about that you should actively sink the qi. With Chinese characters it is written: 氣沉丹田 or “Qi sinks to the Dantian”, The subject here is the character “Qi” and not “I”. There is no “I” here in this sentence as in “I sink the Qi.” It is the Qi that does the sinking. Lately I have become more or less allergic to all kinds of talk about qi because I believe that “sink the qi” is exactly the opposite to what Tai Chi practitioners need to hear. This is exactly the opposite to what you need understand about this concept. I try to give some of the people doing these demonstrations a benefit of a doubt, that the sometimes very well known and mostly respected people, in fact just confuse Qi and Jin. But I often have a feeling that they say things just for the show, to look better than they really are, and that they in fact have no interest to really teach what they show.

Create the internal conditions instead of getting stuck on words

Anyway, Qi or Jin, they are just words, one word that describes what happens on the inside when you establish certain conditions and one word to describe the external expression of the same conditions. As I said in another post, you don’t need to worry about Qi. You don’t need to even think in these terms. All you ever need to do is to practice the basic prerequisites in Tai Chi, and continue to deepen them by merely maintaining them as you continue to practice. When I look at many Tai Chi practitioners, in real life and in videos on the tubes, I see mostly only external movements, often disconnected where the hands lead the body instead of center. Much applications practice seems strictly technical and very much disconnected from the basic body methods of the art. Why are they concerned about basics when they practice a form and leave everything behind when they practice applications? So how you build your foundation in Tai Chi is the most important part of the development in this art, from beginning to the end. And obviously so if you want to become good in this art. If you look for a teacher, make sure that you have a teacher that has a good sense for the basic internal conditions and can teach the foundations in a most practical and detailed manner. If a teacher speak too much or too little about Qi is not important, the only is how well he or she can guide you practically.

 

 

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

A Small Question About Tai Chi Fighting Ranges & Distances.

22 Monday Oct 2018

Posted by David in General Tai Chi, Personal reflections

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Combat, Distances, Fighting Range, Self-defense, Tai Chi Combat, Tai Chi Fighting

Different martial arts focus on specific fighting ranges, one or several. Kicking styles usually prefer a greater distance to the opponent compared to a wrestling art. In General, distances can be summed up to:

  • Outside kicking Range
  • Kicking Range
  • Striking Range
  • Throwing Range
  • Clinch Range
  • Grappling Range
    • (/Ground Fighting Range)

Most combat oriented Tai Chi practitioners agree that Tai Chi is a close range fighting style. Some people call Tai Chi a punching art, others a throwing arts and yet others claim that it’s a grappling art. Still most people agree about the close range, that Tai Chi works best, or is designed mostly for from the distance you can set up a throw, make a clinch or grapple. Yet many seem to be not so sure about how to make Tai Chi work, and they seem to not know about genuine Tai Chi fighting strategies.

If Tai Chi is a close fighting range, then why do so many people who wants to learn how to use Tai Chi, practice fighting by using common distance point sparring? When people try to use this art in sparring, they mostly have a common sparring mind-set. They start on distance, try to keep distance and keep on chasing and trading punches. What does this has to do with close-in fighting? And if you look at how most people practice applications and techniques, they practice while punching and attacking from at least a striking distance. Even when practicing push hands many practitioners stand far from each other, barely reaching each others hand s while rocking back and forth.

No wonder why people question if Tai Chi works or not. They claim that Tai Chi is designed to work at a certain distance, yet they practice Tai Chi combat and self-defence by using mainly another distance. I wonder why?

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

Don’t Worry Too Much About Doing Things Wrong

14 Sunday Oct 2018

Posted by David in General Tai Chi, Personal reflections

≈ 4 Comments

Tags

Life

Teachers put a lot of pressure on their students sometimes not realizing it. Less ambitious students, those who practice Tai Chi for having something to do as a hobby or to have a social platform probably won’t get affected. But it can become a problem for the ambitious practitioners, those who really want to get somewhere in their art and develop real skill. I’ve read things lately as that the student should not experiment too much or try to develop their art by themselves and instead follow the teacher and the curriculum as exactly as possible. Someone wrote that correcting something wrong is hard, so it’s important to practice correct from the beginning. I’ve also read things about the important of things as reverse breathing and a whole lot of descriptions about how to do reverse breathing.

I remember a whole lot of things I struggled with, wondered about and sometimes worried about when I was young. There are so many different things that you should know and understand. There’s a whole lot of pressure on students. Sometimes it’s hard to ask about things, sometimes it might feel embarrassing to ask, and sometimes it might be hard to verbalize questions and express your thoughts.

But the thing is that we all have different roads, we all understand different things faster or slower. Having gaps in the understanding of things, having hard to grasp things and sometimes misunderstand things is a part of every practitioner’s journey. Knowledge always comes from practical experience and trial and error. There’s nothing wrong with experimenting, trying things. There’s nothing wrong with misunderstanding things, being wrong, being corrected or having to re-learn things. If you are dedicated to this art, then your progress will always sometimes be faster, sometimes go slower. Sometimes you will need to re-evaluate things you have done, accept that you have done things wrong and move forward again. Occasionally you might want to laugh at yourself or curse at yourself. And all of this is okay. Your journey will never be straight and no wrong turn you make can eventually stop you from going forward and reach your goal as long as you continue to practice and try to keep it in sight.

One very wise man said that every kind of human development and progress have a certain pattern that can be described as “two steps forward, one step back.” This is very true and if you continue you continue your Tai Chi journey you will always experience the truth of this statement. You will always go backwards now and then, but the road still leads forward. Don’t worry too much about rules, restrictions and about what you need to do, what, when or how often. There is no absolute path and every teacher has different ideas about what is right and wrong and best and bad. So it’s better to take it all not so seriously and to not worry too much. Rather important, in my opinion because your road will be long, is to have fun and try to find ways to enjoy the practice, alone as well as with others. And as you will certainly screw things up along the way, my friendly advice is that, if you already don’t know how, should take things lightly and be ready to laugh at yourself.
… And you know this already, that life is short, so make sure you always enjoy what you do.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

Subscribe

  • RSS - Posts
  • RSS - Comments

Top Posts

  • What Tai Chi Style Should I Choose? A Short Guide to 13(!) Tai Chi Styles
  • On Weight Lifting & Strength Training and T’ai Chi Ch’uan
  • Taiji Ba Jin - A guide to The Eight Jins or "Energies" in T'ai Chi Ch'uan
  • Reclaiming the Scapula with Tai Chi Chuan
  • Long Forms vs Short Forms - What Should You Start to Learn?
  • Tai Chi Chuan - The Snake and Crane Art of Kung Fu

Tai Chi Blogs

Recent Posts

  • How to Trust your Own Muscle Memory & Body Knowledge – Stop Fighting Your ‘Better’ Self.
  • Notice: Tai Chi Glossary
  • Practical Practice Comes First, Understanding Theory Is Secondary
  • On “Waist” in Tai Chi Chuan: The Waist is Not What You Think
  • …Intermission…
  • Understanding Balance and Gravity
  • ‘Body Mechanics’ as Body ‘Language’
  • Heavy Bags Allowed in Tai Chi? – An Introduction to Punching Stuff: Punching – Part II
  • What is a Punch in Tai Chi Chuan? – Tai Chi Punching Part I
  • Understanding Your Enemy

Categories

  • Advanced Tai Chi Theory (14)
  • Basic concepts (53)
  • Form practice (13)
  • General Tai Chi (154)
  • Interviews (6)
  • Personal reflections (87)
  • Push Hands (5)
  • Reviews (2)
  • The Tai Chi Classics (4)
  • Uncategorized (6)

Recent Comments

  • Robin Wu on What Tai Chi Chuan Was Lost in Translation? – Old Yang Style, History & Myths
  • David on How to Trust your Own Muscle Memory & Body Knowledge – Stop Fighting Your ‘Better’ Self.
  • Michael Babin on How to Trust your Own Muscle Memory & Body Knowledge – Stop Fighting Your ‘Better’ Self.
  • David on My View On The Tai Chi Ruler and its Practice
  • Donald on My View On The Tai Chi Ruler and its Practice
  • David on Practical Practice Comes First, Understanding Theory Is Secondary
  • Rick Matz on Practical Practice Comes First, Understanding Theory Is Secondary
  • David on Tai Chi and the word Yielding as an incomplete concept

Tai Chi related blogs

  • A Canadian Blog on Yang Taijiquan
  • Capitol Hill Tai Chi Blog
  • Cook Ding's Kitchen
  • Journey to Emptiness
  • Tai Chi Notebook
  • Taigerchi
  • Taiji Journal
  • The Internal Athlete

Resources

  • Brennan Translation Classic texts translated from Chinese to English
  • China From Inside Jarek’s page on the Internal Arts
  • Chinese Martial Arts articles by Sal Canzonieri Natural Traditional Chinese Martial Arts – articles by Sal Canzonieri
  • Tai Chi Forum Portal and resource page for Tai Chi and related arts.
  • Tai Chi Sticks and Rulers – Handmade
  • The Dao Bums Forum Daoist related discussions forum
  • The Qi Journal Tai Chi and Qigong Journal Online
  • The Rum Soaked Fist Forum Chinese Internal Martial Arts Forum

Subjects & Tags

Bagua Body method Combat Dantian Fighting Form Form practice intent Internal Kung Fu Interviews Learning meditation Mind Neidan neijia Push hands Q&A Qi Relaxation Rooting Self-defense Shenfa Song Tai Chi Tai Chi Combat Tai Chi form Taiji Taijiquan Teaching Yi

Thoughts on Tai Chi - Blog Directory OnToplist.com
Martial arts Blog Directory

Martial arts Blog Directory

Recent Posts

  • How to Trust your Own Muscle Memory & Body Knowledge – Stop Fighting Your ‘Better’ Self.
  • Notice: Tai Chi Glossary
  • Practical Practice Comes First, Understanding Theory Is Secondary
  • On “Waist” in Tai Chi Chuan: The Waist is Not What You Think
  • …Intermission…

Recent Comments

Robin Wu on What Tai Chi Chuan Was Lost in…
David on How to Trust your Own Muscle M…
Michael Babin on How to Trust your Own Muscle M…
David on My View On The Tai Chi Ruler a…
Donald on My View On The Tai Chi Ruler a…

Archives

  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • February 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • November 2014
  • November 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013

Categories

  • Advanced Tai Chi Theory
  • Basic concepts
  • Form practice
  • General Tai Chi
  • Interviews
  • Personal reflections
  • Push Hands
  • Reviews
  • The Tai Chi Classics
  • Uncategorized

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • Thoughts On Tai Chi
    • Join 116 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Thoughts On Tai Chi
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
%d bloggers like this: